Editorial standards

How we test

Most buying guides are a specification sheet with a price next to it. This is what sits behind ours: the checks that decide a score, why a winner wins, who pays for the site, and how to tell us we got something wrong.

Nothing in a guide here is placed, sponsored or reviewed by a brand before it publishes, and every page that carries a buying link says so directly under the headline. How that promise is checked is set out below.

01 What we check

The same checks run whether a unit costs $180 or $2,400. We write down what we measured rather than what the box says, because the box is where most of the mistakes in this category start.

Field and bench checks, recorded for every unit
CheckWhat we record
Ranging accuracyTen readings at 50, 150, 300 and 600 yards against a measured target. We record the spread, not just the average: a unit that reads 301 once and 280 the next time is not accurate, however good the mean looks.
Low lightThe last usable reading after sunset, and whether the display washes out the view or leaves your eyes adjusted for the walk back.
Glass and coatingsEdge softness, colour fringing on backlit branches, and flare when the sun sits within about 20° of the line of sight.
Eyepiece and fitUsed with and without glasses. Eye relief, diopter range, and whether the eyecups hold the position you set them to.
BuildHinge play, focus drag, battery door, lens-cap fit, and what survives a knock off a tailgate.
Carried weightWeighed with battery and strap fitted. The published figure usually is not.

02 How a guide is scored

Each product is scored out of ten in four categories, then averaged on these weights:

Scoring weights
CategoryWeight
Optical quality40%
Build and reliability25%
Ease of use20%
Value at today’s price15%

The weights are deliberately blunt. A high optical score cannot rescue a rangefinder that fogs in the rain or flattens a battery in a morning: a failure in the build column caps the total instead of being averaged away. Value is scored against the price on the day we check it, which is why a pick can leave a guide without anything about the product itself changing.

“Best” means best for the job named in the heading, at a price a reader can pay today. When two units sit within a point of each other we recommend the cheaper one and say why. When nothing at a given price is worth buying, the guide says so rather than filling the slot.

03 What the sample size means

The number of units behind a guide varies: some are built on three long-term units we have carried through a season, others on a bench session with fifteen. Where a count is published, it is distinct models compared, not the number of links in the copy, and we would rather tell you which of the two you are reading.

If a maker supplies a unit for testing, the guide says so. Anything we could not use outdoors — a unit that arrived dead, or a model we only handled on a trade-show stand — is left out of the ranking rather than described from its specification sheet.

04 Prices and updates

Amazon prices change hourly, and a guide quoting last quarter’s price is worse than no guide at all. Rankings are re-checked on a rolling schedule, and again whenever a pick’s price moves far enough to change which unit is the better buy.

Buy links point at Amazon search results when a model is sold in several versions — lens size, colour, bow mode — because a fixed product link goes stale the moment a seller changes the listing. That is why a link sometimes lands you on a search page rather than a single product.

05 Who pays for this

Optics Boom is funded by Amazon Associates commission. If you buy through a link, we may earn a few percent, and the price you pay is the same either way.

That is the entire model. Brands cannot buy a place in a guide, sponsor a ranking, or see copy before it publishes. The commission rate does not rise with the price of the product you choose, and a pick with no affiliate link still gets picked when it is the right answer.

06 What you will not find here

  • Star ratings lifted from Amazon and reprinted as though we had scored them.
  • Verdicts written from a specification sheet with no unit in hand.
  • Top-ten padding. If four products are worth buying, the guide has four.
  • Countdown timers, stock warnings, or list prices that were never charged.
  • Sponsored placements, in any form.

07 Corrections

If something here is wrong — a discontinued model still listed, a specification that does not match the unit, a price that has moved — send us the page and the detail. Corrections are made to the page and the update date changes with them; we do not quietly rewrite a verdict. Contact us here.

Where a claim cannot be verified, it gets cut. A short guide with numbers we can stand behind is worth more than a long one with numbers we cannot.

08 Who writes this

Guides are written and maintained in-house, and the same desk that tests the units signs off on the ranking and keeps the correction log.

Optics Boom review desk

Rangefinders · binoculars · golf optics

Every guide is signed off by one desk and re-checked on a schedule: prices re-verified, discontinued picks pulled, and the date at the top of the page changed to say when it last happened. Read how we test.

Something on this page out of date? Tell us and we will fix it.